The Penrith Panthers, once the NRL’s benchmark for dominance, are in the midst of a worrying slide, prompting calls for a cultural reset. Pundits and former players have pointed out the team’s lack of the “hard edge” and “swagger” that once made them nearly unstoppable. Central to the concerns is star halfback Nathan Cleary, whose recent form slump has mirrored the Panthers’ collective downfall.
In recent matches, the Panthers have looked a shadow of their former selves. A string of losses and uncharacteristic defensive lapses have exposed a team that appears to have lost its identity. “They don’t look dangerous anymore,” one analyst said, calling out Cleary’s quiet influence on the field as a sign of deeper issues within the squad.
Critics argue that Penrith’s once-feared physicality and mental toughness are missing in action. The fear factor that intimidated opponents and gave the Panthers a psychological edge has vanished. Without that, the reigning champions are struggling to assert themselves.
Restoring their trademark aggression and confidence is now seen as critical. That means Cleary, as the team’s leader and playmaker, must rediscover his sharpness and inspire those around him. Fans and pundits alike agree: until Penrith get their “swagger” back, their grip on the NRL throne will continue to loosen.
As the Panthers prepare for crucial fixtures ahead, the focus will be on reclaiming their intimidating presence. The next few rounds could define their season—and their legacy.
